Pitfalls to Colonial Research (Cont.)

2. Second, always review recent literature (especially periodical articles) for the most current status of research on a Colonial ancestor.

This is important because newer research may have proven earlier hypothesis false. Take the time necessary to study all the facts. Particularly become acquainted with periodical literature. For example, someone wanted to know if his James Bruce was the one related to Robert the Bruce. Looking at the PERSI at ProQuest’s Heritage Quest PERSI index, I did a PEOPLE search with these two criteria:

Surname Bruce Examples: Smith, Smit*, Smith and Brown
Keywords Scotland Examples: Irish, Civil War, Quakers
Periodical  
Examples: New England, Military, Everton

There were several articles available on the Bruce family but these looked most interesting:

5. James Bruce-Margaret McMahon fam., ca. 1744+, Scotland; VA, MD, KY
Keys To the Past. Boerne TX: Apr 2000. Vol. 19 Iss. 1

6. Bruce origins, Aberdeenshire, Scotland
Aberdeen and North East Scotland Family History Society Journal. Aberdeen Scotland: Autumn 1989. Vol. - Iss. 32

8. Robert the Bruce, guerilla hero, Scotland
Highlander. Vandalia OH: Jan 1988. Vol. 26 Iss. 1

10. Bruce family, Scotland
Highlander. Vandalia OH: Mar 1987. Vol. 25 Iss. 2

11. James Bruce, Scotland
Highlander. Vandalia OH: Jul 1986. Vol. 24 Iss. 4

15. Bruce families, Scotland
Genealogist. Portugal St., London England: 1882. Vol. 6 Iss. 2

16. Bruce family, Scotland
Genealogist. Portugal St., London England: 1882. Vol. 6 Iss. 3

The earliest articles were recorded in 1882 and the latest in 2000. Of these, six were available in the Family History Library and one was only available at Allen County. I had access to those in the Family History Library through a look-up service. The form below was filled out and sent to Allen County for the one not available there.

Periodical Source Index (PERSI) Order Form

Name:____Karen Clifford_______________________________________
Address:__2863 West 370 North__________________________________
_________Provo, UT 84601_____________________________________

To obtain copies of articles in the PERSI index, contact the Allen County Public Library Foundation, P.O.Box 2270, Fort Wayne, IN 46801-2270. Send this form describing the articles to be copied, provide the full entry from PERSI and the name of the journal. Request only six articles at a time. The charge is $7.50 for each letter, pre-paid, plus $0.20 per page copied to be billed to you. Requests not acceptable by phone, fax, or e-mail. Please allow 6-8 weeks.


Title of article: James Bruce-Margaret McMahon fam., ca. 1744+, Scotland; VA, MD,KY
Title of journal: Keys To the Past ____________________________________
Code: TXKP Vol: 19 No: 1 Mon: Apr Yr: 2000

In the meantime, I started to search for the original documents of Scotland that were available in the Family History Library. I discovered that the time period of the client’s ancestor immigrant in the area was during the years when the documents were destroyed in Scotland. They were lost during an approximate 20 year time period. I therefore was curious as to how the authors of these articles arrived at their conclusions. This brings us to the third caution.


previous page next page